Elizabeth’s involvement in her subjects’ lives deepens as the story goes on. She slowly starts to take on Gracie’s mannerisms, leading to an unsettling scene in which Portman, directly facing the camera, recites a monologue as Gracie. Because it was filmed as a single shot, Haynes gave Portman the room to do multiple takes. “The eight takes that Natalie did, someday need to be shared, because of just the most extraordinary performative exploration and nuance,” says Haynes. “Each take has its own integrity, is complete unto itself, but has absolute distinctions from the next.”
In a weird turn of events, the take that Haynes chose to use includes a moment when a truck unexpectedly drove by the set in downtown Savannah, creating a low growl underneath her monologue. Like much about this project, Todd was sure it was a sign. “It was just like, Holy shit,” says Haynes. “It was just another little indicator that that was the one.”